• NotSo9to5
  • Posts
  • You're Applying At The Wrong Career Level

You're Applying At The Wrong Career Level

How aiming too high (or too low) is quietly costing you interviews

INSIDE THIS ISSUE:

  • This week’s vetted remote roles

  • The signs you're targeting the wrong level

  • When to stretch vs. when you're wasting time

  • How to recalibrate without underselling yourself

Hi Freedom Seeker,

Most people assume the problem is their resume.

Sometimes it is.

But a lot of the time, you're just applying at the wrong level.

Too senior → you look underqualified.
Too junior → you look like a flight risk.

Either way, you get ignored.

Here’s how to figure out where you actually sit—and apply accordingly.


🚀 Weekly Vetted Remote Job Picks

1️⃣ Company: GitLab

🔷 Role: Customer Success Engineer

🔷 Location: USA

🔷 Type: Full-time, fully remote

🔷 Perks: Remote-first environment, equity, flexible PTO

🔷 Salary: Competitive

➡️ Apply Here

2️⃣ Company: Kraken

🔷 Role: Data Analyst

🔷 Location: USA, Canada, UK

🔷 Type: Full-time, fully remote

🔷 Perks: Remote first culture, flexible hours

🔷 Salary: Competitive

➡️ Apply Here

3️⃣ Company: Kraken

🔷 Role: EU Affiliate Manager

🔷 Location: UK, Europe

🔷 Type: Full-time, fully remote

🔷 Perks: Remote first culture, flexible hours

🔷 Salary: Competitive

➡️ Apply Here

THE LEVEL MISMATCH PROBLEM

AIMING TOO HIGH

You’re applying to roles that require:

  • 7–10 years of experience

  • Leadership or ownership of major projects

  • Clear impact at scale

But your experience is closer to:

  • Supporting roles

  • Execution, not ownership

  • Limited scope

Hiring managers don’t “take a chance” here.
They filter you out fast.

AIMING TOO LOW

This one’s more subtle.

You meet (or exceed) every requirement.
But that’s the problem.

They see:

  • Overqualification

  • Higher salary expectations

  • Risk you’ll leave quickly

So they pass—even though you could do the job easily.

HOW TO READ THE LEVEL CORRECTLY

Job descriptions don’t just list skills.
They signal seniority.

Look for:

Scope of work

  • “Assist with” = junior

  • “Own” or “lead” = mid/senior

Decision-making

  • Following processes vs. creating them

Impact

  • Team-level vs. company-wide

Experience language

  • “Familiar with” vs. “proven track record”

If most of the language feels like a stretch, it probably is.

WHEN TO STRETCH (AND WHEN NOT TO)

STRETCH WHEN:

  • You meet ~70–80% of the requirements

  • You’ve done similar work, just at a smaller scale

  • The gap is level, not type of experience

Example:
You’ve led small projects → applying to lead bigger ones

DON’T STRETCH WHEN:

  • You’ve never done the core responsibility

  • The role requires managing people and you haven’t

  • You’d need to learn multiple fundamentals from scratch

That’s not a stretch. That’s a different job.

QUICK SELF-CHECK

Ask yourself:

  • Have I already done most of this job, just in a smaller way?

  • Can I point to specific results that translate?

  • Would I feel uncomfortable—but not lost—doing this on day one?

If it’s “lost,” you’re too early.
If it’s “bored,” you’re too late.

WHAT TO DO INSTEAD

IF YOU’RE AIMING TOO HIGH

  • Drop down one level

  • Reframe your experience with more ownership and outcomes

  • Build proof (projects, freelance, internal opportunities)

IF YOU’RE AIMING TOO LOW

  • Move up one level in your applications

  • Emphasize impact, not tasks

  • Remove overly basic responsibilities from your resume

THE REALITY

There’s a narrow band where you’re:

  • Qualified enough to be credible

  • Slightly stretched so you’re interesting

That’s where interviews happen.

Not at the extremes.

WHAT YOU’RE PROBABLY DOING WRONG

APPLYING BASED ON JOB TITLES ALONE
“Manager” at one company ≠ “Manager” at another

IGNORING SCOPE
Your role might sound similar, but the scale is completely different

TRYING TO SKIP LEVELS
Career growth usually happens one step at a time, not three

NEED HELP FIGURING OUT YOUR ACTUAL LEVEL?

That’s what I do in my Resume Strategy sessions.

We’ll break down:

  • What level you’re currently operating at

  • What roles you should realistically target

  • How to position your experience to match that level

So you stop guessing and start getting responses.

Reply with "WHAT LEVEL AM I?" and I’ll walk you through it.

Until next week,
Sami

Interested in getting your product/ remote job offering in front of highly engaged remote workers?