• NotSo9to5
  • Posts
  • Why Your Resume Gets Rejected In The First 10 Seconds

Why Your Resume Gets Rejected In The First 10 Seconds

What hiring managers actually look for in that initial scan

INSIDE THIS ISSUE:

  • The quick scan that determines everything

  • This week's hot & vetted remote job picks

  • What they're looking for in 10 seconds

  • How to pass the initial test

  • The formatting mistakes that kill you instantly

Hi Freedom Seeker,

Your resume doesn't get read. It gets scanned.

Hiring managers spend about 7-10 seconds on the first look. They're not reading every word. They're scanning for specific things that tell them whether to keep going or move to the next application.

If your resume doesn't pass that quick scan, nothing else matters. Your experience, your achievements, your perfect formatting for the rest of the page - none of it gets seen.

Here's what actually happens in those first 10 seconds and how to make sure you pass the test.


🚀 Weekly Vetted Remote Job Picks

1️⃣ Company: ExtraHop

🔷 Role: Customer Success Manager

🔷 Location: USA

🔷 Type: Full-time, fully remote

🔷 Perks: Flexible PTO, competitive benefits package

🔷 Salary: $90,000 - $100,000 per year (+commission)

➡️ Apply Here

2️⃣ Company: Array

🔷 Role: Account Manager

🔷 Location: Canada, US

🔷 Type: Full-time, fully remote

🔷 Perks: Remote first culture, Summer Fridays, unlimited PTO

🔷 Salary: $120,000 (base salary)

➡️ Apply Here

3️⃣ Company: Qualio

🔷 Role: Customer Success Associate

🔷 Location: EMEA

🔷 Type: Full-time, fully remote

🔷 Perks: Remote-first culture, unlimited PTO, flexible holidays, home office budget

🔷 Salary: Competitive

➡️ Apply Here

WHAT THEY'RE LOOKING FOR IN 10 SECONDS

RELEVANT JOB TITLES

They scan your current or most recent role first. If it's close to what they're hiring for, they keep reading. If it's completely different, they're already moving on.

"Customer Success Manager" applying for customer success? Good.

"Sales Associate" applying for customer success? They'll probably skip to the next resume unless something else catches their eye immediately.

Your most recent title matters more than anything else on your resume.

RECOGNIZABLE COMPANIES OR CLEAR CONTEXT

They don't need to know every company you've worked for. But they need to quickly understand what kind of company it was.

"Marketing Manager at SaaS startup" tells them something.

"Marketing Manager at ABC Corp" with no context tells them nothing.

If your companies aren't well-known, add one line of context: "50-person B2B software company" or "Series A fintech startup."

RECENT RELEVANT EXPERIENCE

They're looking at dates. If your relevant experience is from 5 years ago and you've been doing something completely different since, that's a problem.

Current role + relevant = you move forward. Current role + not relevant = you probably don't.

VISUAL SCANNABILITY

Can they find information quickly? Or is it a wall of text?

Clear section headers, consistent formatting, white space - these make the 10-second scan possible. Dense paragraphs make them give up.

FORMATTING MISTAKES THAT KILL YOU INSTANTLY

WALLS OF TEXT

If your job descriptions are 8-line paragraphs, they're not reading them. Break it up. Use bullets. Make it scannable.

CREATIVE LAYOUTS THAT CONFUSE

Graphics, columns, unconventional sections - these might look cool but they make scanning harder. Hiring managers want to find information quickly, not figure out your design.

IMPORTANT INFO BURIED

If your relevant skills or achievements are at the bottom of the page, they'll never get there. Front-load the important stuff.

NO CLEAR HIERARCHY

Everything looks equally important, so nothing stands out. Use formatting (bold, size, spacing) to guide their eyes to what matters most.

HOW TO PASS THE 10-SECOND TEST

LEAD WITH YOUR STRONGEST STUFF

Your most recent, most relevant role should be obvious and easy to find. If you're a customer success manager, that title should jump off the page.

USE CLEAR SECTION HEADERS

"Work Experience" or "Professional Experience" "Skills" or "Core Competencies" "Education"

Don't get creative here. Use standard headers they're scanning for.

ADD CONTEXT WHERE NEEDED

If you worked at companies nobody knows, add one line explaining what they do. This helps them understand your background faster.

"Senior Analyst at DataCorp (B2B analytics platform, 200 employees)"

MAKE YOUR FIRST BULLET COUNT

The first achievement under each role gets read. The rest might not. Put your most impressive, relevant accomplishment first.

KEEP IT CLEAN

Consistent formatting. Readable font. Enough white space. Make their job easy.

THE REALITY

You're not fighting against unfair standards. You're working within the reality of how hiring actually happens.

Hiring managers review 50-100+ resumes for every position. They have to scan quickly. If your resume makes that hard, they move on.

It's not personal. It's practical.

Your job is to make sure the most important information is visible in that first scan. If you pass the 10-second test, they'll actually read the rest.

NEED YOUR RESUME TO PASS THE SCAN?

My Professional Resume Rewrite service rebuilds your resume specifically to pass that initial scan.

Clear hierarchy. Front-loaded achievements. Scannable formatting. Everything positioned so the most important info gets seen in the first 10 seconds.

Here's what you get:
✅ Resume restructured for maximum scannability
✅ Relevant experience and skills prominently placed
✅ Clear formatting that guides hiring managers' eyes
✅ Context added where needed for quick understanding
✅ Two rounds of revisions to get it perfect

Most clients start getting interview requests within 2 weeks because their resume finally passes the quick scan test.

If you want both resume and cover letter, the Resume + Cover Letter Bundle gives you both optimized together.

Stop losing opportunities in the first 10 seconds. Let's make sure you pass the scan.

Reply with "FIX MY RESUME" and let's rebuild it to actually get read.

Until next week,
Sami

P.S. Print out your resume. Look at it for 10 seconds. Be honest - can you quickly identify the most important information? If you can't, hiring managers can't either.

Interested in getting your product/ remote job offering in front of highly engaged remote workers?